Matthew Yglesias has a reputation for being a 'reasonable' liberal blogger,
but does this
seem 'reasonable' to you?
Ed Kilgore has an excellent post on the oddly backward nature of John
McCain's current "biography tour" and the general weirdness of the
campaign emphasizing the idea that their candidate is genetically programmed
to monger war through his jingoistic heritage (or something). Ed notes the analogy
to Bob Dole's 1996 campaign, the last time the GOP thought having an old man
talk fondly about long-past suffering was a good way to win elections. Relatedly,
I think it was Matt Stoller who pointed out recently that the candidate with
the more impressive military record lost in 1992 and 1996 and 2000 and 2004
so there's reason to doubt that McCain's genuinely impressive military record
will serve as an ace in the hole for his campaign.
What I'll say on behalf of this strategy is that it's the best way I can
think of to try to take advantage of older people's potential discomfort with
the idea of a woman or a black man in the White House that doesn't involve exploiting
racism or sexism in a discreditable way. McCain's putting together an identity
politics counter-narrative steeped in nostalgia; it didn't work against a white
southerner running on a very cautious agenda, but 2008 is going to see the Democrats
nominating an unorthodox candidate running on a more liberal agenda.
Yglesias is arguing, incredibly, that McCain's focus on his military record
is both racist and sexist at the same time. Matt might actually believe this
- he seems to be the type who sees racism lurking under every rock. Check out
this Blogginheads.tv diavlog
with Ann Althouse and go to the section called 'racists on a place' and tell
me if he isn't all too willing to hurl the charge of racism in a very knee-jerk
and unreasonable way.
The charges of 'racism' from the left seem to be coming much quicker and heavier
in the aftermath of the Wright debacle. For example, check out this post entitled
"John
McCain's Racist Dogwhistle in Meridian, Mississippi" in which Matt
Stoller claims that John McCain gave a speech at Meridian, Mississippi because
it is only 40 miles from Philadelphia, Mississippi, which is where the Mississippi
Burning murders took place.
Stoller says that "McCain also has some military history in the town",
conveniently forgetting to mention that the airfield there is named after McCain's
grandfather, and that McCain was a flight instructor there. But no, the real
reason McCain went to Meridian is so he can send coded signals to all the KKK
cells out there that he is their guy.
Get used to it, this is just the tip of the iceberg. If Obama wins the nomination,
we will have many more liberal bloggers and pundits interpreting
and translating all the coded racism out there for our convenience. How these
liberals all became experts in this field will go unexplained, but never mind
you racist.
P.S. Now the left is starting to experiment with 'swiftboating' McCain as well, such as this comment under a different Yglesias post:
Remember, the highlight of McCain's military career was his losing his airplane.
What do you expect?
This is pretty odious. I wonder if this commenter knows about the fire aboard the U.S.S. Forrestal that killed 134 sailors, which was started by a Zuni rocket misfired from McCain's plane. Is the left really going to try to make fun of things like that?
Somehow, I don't see this John 'Crash' McCain meme taking off the way the memes about Kerry's Vietnam service did.